They Made $0 for 4 Years. Then Built a $22B Startup | The Kalshi Story

EO 31min 5 min #14
They Made $0 for 4 Years. Then Built a $22B Startup | The Kalshi Story
Watch on YouTube

Summary

  • Kalshi, a regulated prediction market startup, raised a $1 billion Series F round at a $22 billion valuation — double its valuation from just five months earlier — after spending four years fighting legal battles to become the first fully regulated U.S. prediction market exchange. The company’s story is one of extreme conviction, regulatory-first strategy, and explosive growth once legal barriers fell.

From Ballet to Building a $22B Startup

  • Tarek Mansour, Kalshi’s co-founder, grew up in Lebanon and trained professionally as a ballet dancer in Brazil, often sleeping only four hours a night while balancing school and dance.
    • That background instilled in him a discipline and comfort with delayed gratification — rehearsing for a year for a single hour on stage — that directly shaped his approach to building Kalshi.
    • He chose MIT for undergrad specifically to be pushed out of his comfort zone, and made the difficult decision to quit ballet entirely rather than let his skills deteriorate.

Conviction: 65 Lawyers Said No

  • The idea for Kalshi emerged from Tarek’s 2016 internship at Goldman Sachs, where he noticed that institutional investors cared less about asset prices than about binary outcomes — would Brexit happen, would Trump win — but had no precise way to trade those views.
    • The “Trump trade” of shorting the S&P 500 was a blunt instrument: people who correctly predicted Trump’s win still lost money.
    • Tarek and co-founder Luana Lopes Lara connected the dots while working at proprietary trading firm Five Rings in the winter of 2017–2018, realizing there was no legal, liquid, large-scale prediction market in the U.S.
  • They called 60–65 lawyers in a single day; none said it was possible.
    • Through contacts, they reached Jeff, a regulatory expert who laid out the enormous difficulty of becoming a regulated exchange and clearinghouse under 23 core principles.
    • By the following Monday, Tarek and Luana had written a full analysis of how they would satisfy all 23 rules, which convinced Jeff to join them.

Legitimacy: Four Years to Earn the Right to Launch

  • Kalshi’s founding principle was “regulatory first” — they would not launch, market, or build a public product until they had full legal approval.
    • This decision was crystallized at a Y Combinator hackathon where their demo was immediately flagged as illegal by Michael Seibel, who nonetheless admitted the founders sounded motivated.
    • While other YC batch companies showed week-over-week growth metrics, Kalshi’s progress was measured in lawyer meetings, regulatory filings, and policy documents.
  • Competitors launched offshore without licenses, making Kalshi’s path look stagnant by comparison.
    • The founders stayed committed because they believed prediction markets could bring objective, truthful forecasting to society’s most important questions.
    • They viewed the price generated by these markets as a single, powerful data point — an unbiased forecast from millions of people putting real money behind their beliefs.

Payoff: Four Years of Fighting, Four Weeks to Scale 100x

  • After more than two years of trying to work with regulators through normal channels — including a public comment period with 200 submissions from prominent academics — Kalshi realized engagement wasn’t working.
    • They made the extraordinary decision to sue their own regulator, the CFTC, betting that they were legally right and that these markets should exist.
    • Every judge who reviewed the case ruled in Kalshi’s favor, first at the district court level and then at the appeals court.
  • Winning the lawsuit triggered the most intense month in the company’s history.
    • A third-party clearinghouse blocked Kalshi from listing the election market, forcing the team to migrate their entire clearinghouse infrastructure — a process that normally takes six months — over a single weekend.
    • The full team worked around the clock for four weeks, scaling 100x overnight.
    • Kalshi gained over 2 million customers in roughly 2 weeks and did over $2 billion in volume, with sign-up and deposit systems buckling under the demand.
    • The company was able to call the 2024 election results before mainstream media, with live probabilities visible throughout election night.

Signal: Not a Casino, a Market for Truth

  • Kalshi’s core argument is that prediction markets are financial markets, not gambling, for two structural reasons:
    • The underlying events are real-world, naturally occurring risks — not artificial constructs like dice rolls.
    • The market structure is neutral: Kalshi doesn’t profit when customers lose, unlike a casino where the house’s revenue equals customer losses.
  • Real money creates real incentives for accuracy.
    • Research shows people express confident political opinions when asked casually, but become far more uncertain when asked to put money behind their predictions.
    • This “put your money where your mouth is” mechanism reduces polarization and surfaces genuine information.
  • As a regulated exchange, Kalshi is subject to the same rules as stock exchanges:
    • Market integrity (fairness) and customer protection (transparency) are enforced.
    • Insider trading is treated identically to insider trading in equities markets.
    • All trades are publicly reported, winners cannot be blocked, and the exchange must remain neutral.

Edge: Where Knowledge Becomes a Market

  • Kalshi’s user base includes full-time traders who have found edges in niche markets:
    • Joel, a former accountant, makes over $200,000 a year trading mention markets — bets on what a specific person will say in a speech — by building databases of historical speeches and tracking administration talking points in real time.
    • Brandon, a 25-year-old public school teacher, made $150,000 on Kalshi, including $8,000 from a single trade where he found inventory data in the HTML source code of Travis Scott’s CD store.
    • Shannon, a Kalshi employee and meteorology graduate, trades weather markets as a form of insurance — buying “yes” on a hurricane hitting her area to offset her $10,000 homeowner’s insurance deductible.
  • Non-sports markets are growing 5x year-over-year and already represent $300–400 million in weekly volume ($15–20 billion annualized), covering economics, politics, culture, and weather.

Scale: From Niche Market to Global Infrastructure

  • Kalshi has gone mainstream, with a significant percentage of Americans now active on the product — many using it as a newsfeed for forecasts rather than actively trading.
    • The company is investing heavily in brand definition to clarify what it is and isn’t.
    • International expansion is a priority to diversify the customer base.
  • The long-term vision is for prediction markets to reach the scale of the stock market, with participation ranging from retail users to major institutions.
    • The founders see the journey as full circle: they first observed demand for binary event trading at Goldman Sachs, Bridgewater, and Citadel, and now aim to build the liquid, regulated markets those institutions can trade on.
    • The company believes it’s still in the early innings, with the potential to cover virtually any topic people care about — from politics and sports to culture and weather.
Back to EO